Placido Polanco's unexpected acceptance of the Phillies' arbitration offer has been hailed by several bloggers as a sign that the team's underwhelming offseason had perhaps changed for the better. Polanco, after all, is a talented, unselfish, and highly versatile player who brings a lot of skills to the table. Unfortunately for the Phils, he's also going to bring a far higher price tag than Chase Utley, his replacement at second base.
Clearly the Phillies had no intention of bringing Polanco back; their offer of arbitration was meant solely to secure draft picks if/when he signed somewhere else. But, oops, that didn't happen, and now the Phils are stuck with an expensive benchwarmer with no obvious place to play. Oh, yeah, and he isn't exactly thrilled to be coming back, either. The problem is that that there are no obvious solutions here. Calls to trade David Bell and install Polanco at third, while understandable, are futile. Bell, you'll recall, had to be overpaid to come to Philadelphia two years ago because of the team's longstanding failure. Like Pat Burrell, his contract renders Bell all but untradeable. If the Phils were going to go over budget -- and if they keep Placido, they will -- they should have used that money to buy more pitching. Ed Wade may grit his teeth and spit out that he's happy to have a player of Polanco's caliber return to the team, but even he knows that, once again, the Phillies couldn't get out of their own way.